Chapter 22 of 26
Two Lives
13 min · 3,222 words
Teviot had not heard the bar go down.
He had listened for it from the Whinlaw gate, with his hand on the wall. He heard her boots cross the floor of her room, and the mattress take her weight, and after that only the water. He stood where he was for a long time.
Then he went round his gates. He did it twice. He sat on the rim of the cistern through the dead hours with the abbey spring going slow in the wall, and he looked at the four sheets on his table from ten feet off.
He had not touched them since Monday. She had told him then that they wanted one line, and he would no more read a page its drafter called unfinished than she would. He had told himself that for three days. It was true. He knew by now that a thing could be true and still be something to hide behind.
Gala came down from the sunrise door shaking sleet off her collar.
“West wind and wet,” she said. “It’s coming in sideways. You’d like it.” She looked at the table, and at him, and went back up without another word.
He sat down on his stool and took up the pages.
Three of them told him what the hall had told him on Monday, in better order. He read every line. He read how the paper had been warm under her palm in one place. He read the banns as the dominie had set them down, and the two gold coins. He read the three reasons in their column on the third page. She had not softened one of them. Below the column she had written that every reason on it was a thing she had settled for him, and that she had seen it only when it was in ink.
He turned the fourth sheet over.
There are two roads from here, and both are yours.
If you will, one of the court may freely give his life to me at midwinter, and the debt is paid. I would take no one’s but yours. You would have a mortal’s span from that day, and the door.
If you will not, I shall stand up at midwinter and show the ring, because it is true. It will fail for want of anyone to pay. After that no scribe of Whinlaw reads the binding again, and no payment can ever be shown and sealed. You would keep your centuries, and you would keep them under the hill. I will not speak the name to change that. I gave the lady my word in writing this morning.
What I feel is the same on both roads. I will say it to your face if you want it said. I will not put it here, where it would read like a price.
I decided for you because I was afraid of what you would choose. Choose.
He read the last line three times. Then he put the sheet down and laid both hands flat on it, as he had seen her lay hers.
He knew which road. He had known it on Monday in the hall, with two hundred of the court staring at him, before he had found the breath to be angry. He was six hundred and seven. He had seventeen gates, a bed cut from four curtains and a wedge of sky. He had counted that out more than once in three nights. He would give all the centuries he had left for fifty years with weather in them and her at the other end of a table.
That had never been the hard part. She had been afraid of his choosing, and he had never once told her what he would choose. He had told her that he loved her and wanted nothing back. He had told her he would kneel by a river. He had lain in the dark and said that somebody might warm his hands, and that he would not ask.
He had been proud of not asking. He looked at that now, and it did not look as well as it had.
***
Gala found him at the Bowden gate in the middle of the morning.
“The lady wants you in the hall. The benches are empty, but they’ll not be for long. The old man has called a matter for noon, with the lamps full, because the scribe wants to see a waterline.”
“What matter?”
“The hall well. Ettrick and Rule have been at each other over it since the frost.” Gala hesitated. “She went to the lady’s chamber yesterday. The scribe did. She was in there the time it takes to trim two wicks, and the lady has not been the same colour since.”
He put on his coat.
Yarrow was not on the high seat. She was standing at the foot of it, in grey, with her net on and a sheet of human paper in her right hand. The Long Hall was bright and bare. Sparks of quartz light lay on the floor between them.
“Read that,” she said, and held it out. “I’m not giving it to you. I want it back.”
He read it. It was Isobel’s plainest hand. He came to or to save myself and stopped, and went on. He came to anything the lady does or leaves undone. He read the date at the foot.
“She brought it to my door,” Yarrow said. “She told me it wouldn’t warm, and that she could lie, and that I must judge for myself what it was worth. She wanted nothing for it. I asked her.”
“What did you say to her?”
“Nothing. I had nothing.” Yarrow took the paper back and looked at it. “I have waited fifty-five years for a woman of Whinlaw to take my life, cousin. I knew one would come. I shut the door on their scribes. I kept that one’s mother standing in the snow. I wrote a letter to trap this one for a year and a day, and offered her gold, and set a writer to rob her kirk. I named her blood in front of my whole court on the very night she meant to tell you herself. And yesterday she walked into my chamber and gave my life back to me. She gave it against her own safety. She had worked out what I might do to her, and she wrote that into it.”
“She would.”
“I’ve turned it over all night. I can’t find the hook in it. I’ve looked as hard as the old man looks for a loose thread.” Her mouth twisted. “I owe her, and she’ll not ask for it. I can tell you that I rest very badly.”
“Why show me?”
“Because Gala has ears, and I know what was said across your cistern on Monday. You told her how it read.” Yarrow’s dark eyes came up to his. “You raised me. You taught me at six years old that we can’t lie, and that our only freedom is in which true thing we choose to say. I chose mine on Monday. I had a dozen true ways to tell that hall, and I picked the one that counted her fourteen days aloud. I know why I picked it. Do you know why you picked yours?”
He did not answer at once. He could not give her the easy thing, and he found he did not want to.
“It was the one that would hurt her most,” he said. “I told her she’d done what her grandmother did, with my face in front of her. It was true. I had other true things. I could have said that I was hurt. I could have said that I’d have chosen her in a breath. I said the cold one, and I called it honesty.”
“Yes.”
“She was afraid, and I punished her for it.”
“You did.” Yarrow said it without heat. “I’ll tell you the other half, since I’m in debt this morning and it makes me generous. You have never in your life asked for a thing. You granted. You gave leave. You took my place at that sill, and you didn’t once ask me whether I’d have it so. I’d have said no, and you knew it. Then you stood inside a door for fifty-five years, waiting for Whinlaw to say a word. You’ve been waiting on that scribe since Hallowe’en. You wait at doors, cousin. You think it’s courtesy.”
“I thought it left her free.”
“It left her to do all the asking. And when she didn’t ask, she had to guess what you wanted.” Yarrow folded the paper along its crease. “What’s so hard in it? I ask for things daily. I asked a writer for lamp oil on credit.”
He looked down the bright hall to the stair, and the rock at the top of it.
“It feels like begging,” he said. “I sat that seat for a hundred and thirty-eight years. A lord who asks can be told no.”
“You’re not a lord. You’ve told her so yourself, more than once.” There was noise at the arches now. The first of the court were coming in for noon. Yarrow turned toward the seat and then stopped. “I’ll say one thing more, and you may make of it what you can. I’ve a seat, and I mind about it still. That’s for another day. Today I’ve a paper in my hand that I can’t answer. Go and do better than I did.”
***
The hall well stood under the third great root, a ring of stone no higher than a knee, with a dipping chain. By noon two hundred of the court were packed round it and along the benches. Isobel had set her board on the nearest table. She had her good coat on. She was thin and pale, and her hands were perfectly steady on the paper.
She saw him come to the arch. Her eyes held his for one breath. She asked him nothing with them. Then she turned back to her work, and he understood that she was keeping her word about not standing over him.
“State it,” she said. “Ettrick, you’re the elder.”
Ettrick was a broad woman from the spinners’ gallery, with wool grease on her cuffs. “The well is the hall’s, and the hall may draw. We scour fleece on the first days of the week. We’ve drawn from that well since before he had a brew-house.”
“And on the first days of the week I mash,” said Rule. He was thin and sour, and he smelled of apples. “I let down my bucket and I bring up mud. In the frost I lost a whole brewing. She’d drained it to the stones.”
“Does either of you say the other has no right to draw?”
Neither could say it. The benches stirred.
“Then what’s in dispute is how much, and nobody here knows what the well gives.” Isobel turned the pen over in her fingers. He saw her think. Then she looked straight at the arch. “Keeper of the springs. I’m asking you as the one who’d know. What feeds it?”
He came forward through the benches. They made room.
“A seep off the abbey channel,” he said. “It comes in through a crack on the north side, two hands down. I’ve heard it for fifty-four years. It fills a hand’s depth in the hour, more after rain and less in frost. Empty it and you wait from lamps-up to lamps-down for it to brim.”
“Can it be made to give more?”
“Not without taking it from the monks’ share. That’s granted, and I’d not touch it.”
“I’d not ask you to.” She was already writing a heading. “Then here’s my draft. A line is to be cut in the stone inside the well, by the keeper, at a depth he judges will leave a full brewing above the mud. On the first three days of the week the spinners may draw down to that line and no lower. The brewer draws what’s under it. On the other days the well is anyone’s. The line is to say what it’s for, so that nobody need send for a scribe in fifty years.”
“‘For the mash, thus far,’” Teviot said.
Her mouth moved at one corner before she could stop it. “That’ll do. Will the keeper cut it?”
“He will, for a jug of the first brewing. In his own name.”
“That’s between you and the brewer, and I’ll write it in. Do you both agree it?”
They agreed it, with ill grace on both sides, which he had learned was the mark of a fair page. She read each term as it went down. They pricked their thumbs. Ettrick said “Warm,” and Rule said it, and Isobel laid her own hand on the paper last and took it away cold.
Leithen rolled the page into his sleeve and opened his mouth to give the count.
“Remembrancer,” Teviot said. “I’ve a matter. It isn’t on your roll, and it isn’t the court’s. It’s mine.”
The hall went still. Isobel had her rag in her hand. She put it down.
He had thought on the stair that he would say it well. Now he stood in front of her, with the well at his back and two hundred faces round him, and his mouth was dry. He had sat above these people for more than a century. Every one of them was going to hear whether she said no.
That was as it should be. He had kept his asking private for six weeks, and she had been left to guess at it.
“I read your pages at sunrise,” he said. “All four, and the back of the last. You told me to choose. Before I do, I’ve a wrong to own. On Monday I said the cruellest true thing I had. I had kinder ones. I chose that one because you’d frightened me and I wanted you to feel it. You were afraid, and I answered that by hurting you. I was wrong in it, Isobel, and I’m sorry.”
Her lips had parted. He saw some of the court turn their heads at the name.
“There’s an older fault under that one. I’ve waited on you since you came through the door. I waited for you to say you wanted me. I gave you my word not to ask a question, and I was proud of keeping it. I told you I loved you and wanted nothing back. That wasn’t so much a lie as a thing left off the page. I wanted a great deal. I never told you what. I left you to work out alone what I’d choose, and you guessed wrong, and I blamed you for the guess.”
“Teviot,” she said, very low.
“I’ve not finished. You taught me that.” He drew a breath. “So I’m asking. I’ve never asked for anything in six hundred years, and I find I’ve no skill at it. Take my life, Isobel Ainslie, and give me yours. I mean it by the old form, with the ring shut. I’m asking in my own name, which the binding leaves me. I ask it whether or not it opens a single door. If the hill stays shut on me at midwinter and every midwinter after, I’d ask it still, and take my Sundays as you take yours.”
Somewhere behind him Gala made a sound like a kettle.
“You’d take a mortal’s span,” Isobel said. Her voice shook. “Fifty years, if you’re lucky. You’d go grey. I wrote it down for you.”
“You did, and I’ve weighed it with my eyes open. I’d rather have a life with an end in it, beside you, than six hundred years more under a hill. I’ve had six hundred. I couldn’t tell you what I did with most of them. I can tell you every day of the last six weeks.” He held out his hand, palm up, as she had once held an apple out to him. “You may say no. I’d deserve it, and the water runs either way, and nobody here will make anything of it. But I’ll not have you guess what I want any more. I want you. I want Kirk Wynd and rain on my neck and your ink on the table. Will you have me?”
She did not turn the pen over. She had no need to decide anything.
She came round the end of the table. She was crying, and she did not seem to mind who saw it.
“Yes,” she said. “I’ll have you. I’d have had you on either road, and I was a fool not to say so on the twenty-seventh of November.” She put her hand in his. It was warm, and it gripped hard. “And here’s the line I couldn’t write. I’d not put it on paper, and I’d not say it with a false thing beside it. There’s nothing beside it now. I love you. I’ve loved you since the snow went to water in your hands, and I told Jessie it was a quarter. I love you, Teviot, and I’m saying it in front of your whole court so that there are two hundred witnesses to it.”
He could not speak. He closed his fingers round hers. He had been told a true thing by someone who was able to lie, and he believed her entirely. He thought that must be how his own word had always seemed to her.
The hall broke. It began with Gala, who shrieked, and it ran down both sides like the Whinlaw water through a lifted gate. They stamped and beat the tables. Quair struck one great chord and lost the rest of it in the noise.
“He’ll be dead at ninety!” Gala shouted. She was crying and laughing together. “Keeper, you’ll be dead at ninety!”
“I know it,” Teviot said. “I asked anyway.”
“Remembrancer!” That was Ettrick. “He asked by the old form. Is that the clause? Is that what’s owed?”
Leithen had not moved from his stool. He waited for the hall to quiet, and it did.
“What the clause asks will be shown at midwinter,” he said. “The lady sealed that, and so did the scribe. What you have heard today is a man asking a woman a question, and her answer. It is no payment yet. A payment must be shown and sealed on the night, and it will need a page.” His ink-dark eyes moved from their joined hands to the high seat. “There are six days. I’d advise the scribe to draft with great care. There are words in this hall that have not yet been spent.”
Teviot looked up the length of the hall.
Yarrow sat on the pale wood in her grey, quite still. She had Isobel’s paper folded in her lap. Her left hand lay closed on top of it. She was looking at the two of them, and he could not read her face at all.
Isobel’s fingers tightened in his.
“Six days,” she said, under the noise, for him alone. “Then we’d best begin tonight. Bring the lamp. I’m asking.”
***