Chapter 16 of 26
Shepherd’s Crooks
11 min · 2,681 words
The Pinks started at seven on Monday, in the low corner, and Sonja stayed with the crew for the first three bins.
The colour was right. Teo held an apple up against the sky and turned it, and the blush went more than halfway round. He set it in the bin as if it were an egg.
“Go on,” he said. “You’re hovering. Go and count your buds.”
She went. She walked up through the picked Honeycrisp with her hands in her jacket and her breath smoking. The grass was white, and the sun had not yet come over the hills. She had walked the young block most mornings that year, until the Grannies took every morning of the past week. It was the one job on the place she did for herself alone.
She came in at the end post where Reid had tied the horses a week ago.
The first tree looked wrong before she could have said why. She saw the shape before she saw any detail. The leader should have run straight up past the top wire like a fishing rod. This one bent over at the tip and curled back on itself in a hook, like the handle of a shepherd’s crook.
She stopped. She looked at the next tree, and the one after it.
Every leader in the row was hooked. The side shoots were doing it too, each one bowing at the tip. She reached up and pulled the nearest leader down to her face. The older leaves were sound, going gold at the edges, as they should in October. The newest ones, the last six or eight the tree had made, were cupped like spoons. Their edges had drawn in and crimped. The veins ran side by side like the ribs of a fan, when they should have branched. The stem under them had thickened and twisted a quarter turn.
She knew it on sight. She had seen it in 2019 in a block of young Galas south of Wenatchee, across a fence from a railroad that sprayed its right-of-way. She had walked that block with the grower and the man from the extension office. The extension man had held a shoot tip exactly like this one. “Hormone,” he had said. “Growth regulator. It tells the plant to grow, and it can’t stop, and it twists itself to death.”
It was a weed killer for range and roadsides. Ranchers used it on thistle and knapweed, and highway crews and railroads used it too. No orchardist in the state kept a jug of that kind within a mile of an apple tree.
She let the shoot go. Her hand was steady, which surprised her. The rest of her had gone very cold.
She made herself work, because that was the only thing she knew to do with fear. She walked the first row to its end, and crossed four rows and walked back, and crossed four more. She went through all eight acres that way with her eyes on the tips. It was in every row. Here and there a tree showed it less. Nowhere did a tree show nothing.
Then she looked at the ground, because the ground would tell her how it had come.
The weeds told her. Under every sprinkler head there was a ring of mallow and dandelion, twisted flat with their stems corkscrewed. Past the last head in each row, where the water had not reached, the same weeds stood upright and ordinary. She walked out across the headland to the nearest pears, forty feet away, and pulled down a dozen shoots. They were clean. She went down to the nursery row and knelt beside her bandaged buds, and they were clean too.
Drift off a spray truck came in on the wind. It hit one edge hard and thinned across a block, and it did not care where the sprinklers stopped. This had gone exactly where her water went.
She stood on the ditch road above the intake and looked at the dry channel. The mud in the bottom had cracked into plates.
There had been a smell at five o’clock last Tuesday morning, something like ammonia and something like a new tarp. It had come from this direction. The set had still had an hour to run. She had thought about the county truck, and then she had pulled the quilt up and gone back to sleep.
She had given something an hour once before. She put that thought away, because she could not afford it before breakfast.
“Teo,” she said into the radio. “Cass. Come up to the young-block intake. Just the two of you. Don’t run.”
They came in Teo’s truck. She showed them one tree and let them look at the rest for themselves. Teo took off his hat. Cass walked twenty yards down the row, came back, and stood with her fists against her legs.
“What is it?” Teo asked.
“It’s a growth-regulator herbicide. I don’t know which one. It came in through the water on the last set.” She pointed out the weed rings and the clean pears. “Cass, you shut the valves at six on Tuesday. Did you smell anything?”
Cass’s face had gone white under the freckles. “Something. It was sharp. I thought it was the county, doing the highway.” Her voice cracked. “I thought it was the county, Sonja.”
“So did I, at five. I smelled it from my bed.” She said it flatly, so that Cass would not have to carry it alone. “Listen. The pond pumps are off and they stay off. Nothing gets drawn out of that pond until I know what’s in it. Nobody prunes in here, nobody mows and nobody waters. The crew hears that the boss went to town. That’s all they hear.”
“Will they die?” Teo said. He meant the trees.
“I don’t know. Some of these sprays a tree grows out of in a season. Some of them sit in the ground for years.” She heard how calm she sounded. “I won’t know which until a lab tells me. I’m not guessing with seven thousand trees.”
“It’s ranch,” Cass said. “That’s pasture spray. You said so yourself.”
“I said what kind it is. I didn’t say whose.”
“Who else has it?”
“The county. The railroad. Every outfit from here to the border with a thistle patch.” Sonja looked at her. “I’m going to find out what it is before I say who. Go and check that the pump breakers are locked. Teo, the Pinks are yours.”
She took the sampling kit from the shed. It was a habit from her old job, and she had never needed it at home. It held paper bags and zip bags, a soil probe, a box of nitrile gloves, flagging tape and a cooler. She took ten trees on a grid across the block and tied a strip of orange tape to each. From every one she cut three hooked shoot tips into a paper bag, and pushed the probe into the ground at the drip line and emptied the core into a zip bag. She changed gloves at every tree. She wrote the row and tree number on each bag, with the date and the time. She photographed each tip against the scale on her knife handle.
That made twenty. She scraped a bag of silt from the screen at the intake, and another from the cracked mud of the ditch bed just above it. For the last one she went back to the pears and cut clean shoots from a tree she knew was sound, so that the lab would have something to measure against.
There were twenty-three bags. She packed them in the cooler on ice packs from her own freezer and was on the highway by nine.
It was two hours to Wenatchee, down the Okanogan and then the Columbia, with the orchards bare or gold on the benches above the water. She had driven it every other weekend for six years. She did not turn on the radio. She kept the trees out of her head by doing sums, and the sums were no better. She had 7,200 trees and a note for $310,000. The fruit buds were already made for next fall, and they sat a few inches below those crooked tips.
The lab was a low brick building behind the fairgrounds. The chemist at the counter was a stooped man named Dale Ferris, and he had run leaf tissue for her old nursery every summer. He looked at her face and then at the cooler, and he did not ask how she had been.
He held the first paper bag up to the window and looked through the top.
“That’s a hormone,” he said.
“I know. Which one?”
“It could be any of six. It could be 2,4-D or dicamba, or one of the pyridines. They all bend a shoot like that.” He set the bag down gently. “I’ll run the whole auxin panel on everything you’ve brought. Leaf and soil both. Is this silt?”
“It’s off my intake screen. It came through the ditch.”
His eyebrows went up. He wrote something on the form. “Somebody put it in your water.”
“I’m waiting for you to tell me what somebody put.”
“Fifteen working days for the panel. I can’t make the machine go faster.”
She counted them on the calendar behind his head. “The ninth of November.”
“The ninth. I’ll phone you myself.” He turned the form around for her to sign. “It’s a hundred and eighty-five a sample.”
She wrote the check for $4,255 and did not let herself look at it for long.
“You know what I’m going to say,” Ferris said.
“Don’t water, don’t feed, don’t cut.”
“And don’t pull anything out until spring. A tree can look like the end of the world in October and leaf out fine in April, if it was one of the short-lived ones.” He hesitated. “If it was one of the long ones, you’ll know that in April too.”
“I know.”
“I’m sorry, Sonja. Those are the Cosmic Crisp, aren’t they? You told me about them when you left.”
“Those are the ones,” she said, and went out to the truck.
She was home at half past one. The Pinks were going off in bins along the lane, and she could hear Ramón laughing in the trees. She stood by the pump shed with her phone in her hand for a full minute.
She had not seen Reid since Friday morning. He had phoned on Saturday night, and they had talked for ten minutes about the rain that had not come. He had not asked her for anything. She had lain awake afterward with what he had told her under his window, and with the six days she had left to think about it.
She would have liked to have this one thing separate from that. It was not going to be separate.
He answered on the first ring.
“The young block’s been poisoned,” she said. “With herbicide, through the ditch, on the last set. I need you to come and look at it.”
There was no sound on the line at all for a moment.
“I’m coming,” he said.
He was there in twenty-two minutes. She had felt him the whole way down the valley, and for once the pull was no comfort. He got out of the truck without his hat. She walked him up the lane and in at the end post and stopped beside the first tree.
“Look at the top,” she said.
He looked. He put his hands in his coat pockets and kept them there. He walked into the row, slowly, with his head back. He turned at the fourth tree and looked along the wires, at hook after hook. It was the row where he had touched a fruit bud with one fingertip and said it was like standing in a church.
His face had gone the colour of ash.
“All of it?” he said.
“Every row.”
“Could it have blown in? The county was on the highway.”
She showed him the weed rings, and the clean weeds beyond the last heads, and the clean pears across the headland. He followed each thing she pointed at. She did not have to say any of it twice.
“It went where the water went,” he said.
“Yes. I smelled it at five that morning. I’ve got the silt from the screen at a lab in Wenatchee, with twenty-two other bags. They’ll tell me what it was on the ninth of November.”
“What kind is it?”
“It’s the kind you’d spray on knapweed.”
He took that full in the face. He did not look away from her.
“We spray knapweed,” he said. “So does everybody north of Omak.”
“I know that. I said it to Cass this morning.” She folded her arms, because her hands had finally started to shake. “The gate was shut four days ago. There’s been no water in that ditch since Thursday. Somebody put this in during the one night all year when every tree in here was drinking for twelve hours straight. So I’m asking you one question, and I want you to think before you answer. Who outside my pack knew this block was on water a week ago tonight?”
He did not take time to think.
“My whole table,” he said. “I told them. It was the shipping supper, on the tenth. My mother made a joke about not knowing whose kitchen I’d be in on Monday. I said you wouldn’t have a minute for me, because your young trees were getting their last soak. I said Monday night. I said twelve hours, dusk till daylight. There were thirty wolves in the room, and Hollis asked me what a tree wanted with water in October.” His voice was hoarse. “I gave them the night and the hours, Sonja. I did it to get a laugh off my own back.”
She had asked the question, and she had half known the answer. It still went into her like a blade into green wood.
“Thirty,” she said.
“Thirty. I can write down every name for you. I’ll do it tonight.” He drew a breath. “And you asked who knew, so here’s the rest of the list. Everyone who reads your board knew. Cass knew to the minute, because she shut those valves.”
“No.”
“I’m not saying she did it.”
“Then don’t say her name in here.” She heard her voice go hard and let it. “My wolves do not poison my trees. Cass has stood on that weir at five every morning since April for this block. She cried in front of Teo today.”
“Mine didn’t cut ditch banks, either. I’d have sworn that to you in August.” He said it quietly. “I’m giving you the whole list, with my own people at the top. If I left yours off because of who’s asking, you’d never trust another word I told you.”
That was fair, and she hated that it was. She looked down the row at the bent tips and could not answer him.
“I’m going to find out who did this,” Reid said. “I asked them twice in the cookhouse and I got nothing. I’m done asking a room. I’ll find out, and I’ll bring it to you first, before the law-keepers and before my own mother. I’m not swearing it this time. I swore the last two, and look where we’re standing.”
“Reid—”
“I should have had him in September.”
Grass crackled behind them.
Cass stood ten feet up the row with a padlock key in her fist. Her eyes were red and dry. Sonja did not know how long she had been there. It had been long enough.
Cass was not looking at Sonja. She was looking at the tall man with his hands in his pockets, in the middle of eight acres of ruined trees.
“So the whole Haldane table knew,” she said.
***