Chapter 24 of 26
Four to Three
13 min · 3,221 words
She had 1,140 written on the back of her hand, and she had decided not to wash it off.
Josie had put up Thursday night’s truck with her crew. It had landed at 1:32. She had clocked out at half past six, changed her shirt in the back room, and left her father at the kitchen table with Virgil and a deck of cards. Then she had driven sixty-three miles north with a Brockmeyer’s paper sack on the seat beside her. Nine blue notebooks were in the sack. On top of them was a folder with seventeen logs in it, each signed at the bottom with a name and a store number.
The guard at the front desk of the support center looked at the red vest and reached for the telephone.
“I’m not a delivery,” she said. “Josephine Shriver. They’ve got me down for ten.”
He found her on his sheet. He was writing out a visitor’s pass when a woman came across the lobby at a fast walk. She was small, in a navy sweater, with light brown hair and a hospital lanyard around her neck.
“You’re Josie. I’m Annie. I’m the sister.” She put her hand out. “I’m real. I heard there was some doubt.”
“Kayleigh Dye says thank you. She also says she wants your job.”
“She can have Tuesdays.” Annie did not let go of the hand right away. She had grey-blue eyes, and they were going over Josie as frankly as Opal Hupp’s ever had. “I told him in October to tell you or leave. I want you to know somebody told him.”
“He’s told me a good deal since.”
“I heard that, too. Come on. It’s upstairs.”
The corridor on the second floor was lined with photographs of stores. Josie stopped at the second one. It showed a low tan building with a new script sign and six cars in the lot. She knew the window to the right of the doors. She had turned the lock beside it that morning.
The boardroom had a table as long as her dock. At the far end of it hung a photograph the size of a door. It was the one from the apple butter jar: a woman of thirty-one in a white apron, with her arms crossed and her chin up, in front of that same window.
Opal was right, Josie thought. She had a chin.
Seven people were finding their chairs. She knew two. Dale Kessler nodded to her from the middle of the table. Leo stood at the head of it in a dark suit and a blue tie. He still had the beard. She had never seen him in anything he could not lift a case in, and for a second he looked like the man in the annual letter, the one with the oranges. Then he met her eyes, and he looked like himself, tired and steady. He nodded as Dale had, and no more than that.
There was an empty chair at the foot of the table, under the portrait. She set the sack on the table in front of it and took the notebooks out, one at a time. She stacked them with the first on top.
At ten o’clock Leo called the meeting to order.
“There is one item,” he said. “Before we take it up, I have a statement for the minutes. From October fifteenth until this week I worked nights at Store #2 under the name Leo Fisher. Every director has had that in writing since December. It means I can’t preside over this item and be believed. So I’m handing the chair for it to Mrs. Tackett. I’ll speak when she calls on me, and I’ll speak last.”
He sat down. He moved his chair a foot back from the table, and he folded his hands.
Rosemary Tackett was a broad woman of sixty-nine with a plain grey bob and a man’s wristwatch. She pulled her reading glasses down her nose.
“The item is Ashgrove’s offer. Three billion dollars, and it expires a week from today. I’ve got a motion from Mr. Kessler to accept it, seconded by Mr. Mendel. Before I take discussion, the board will hear from Ms. Shriver, night lead at Store #2, at the invitation of the chair. That’s me. Ms. Shriver, how long do you need?”
“About twenty minutes, ma’am.”
“Take them.”
Josie stood up. Her mouth was dry. She had told a man from Chicago about salad at five in the morning, and that had been easy, because she had been angry and on her own floor. This was carpet. She put her hand on the top notebook, and the cover was soft under her palm, and her voice came out all right.
“I’ve worked at Store #2 since June of 2013. In August of 2024 a computer here in Newark started writing our orders. In September I started writing down what it sent that we threw out. I did it every night, and every Thursday I totaled the week at invoice cost. These are the nine notebooks. I’d like them passed around. Please don’t lose my place in the last one.”
She slid the stack up the table. A dentist’s careful hands took the first one. That would be the cousin. The woman beside him, with the long jaw, turned her wedding ring and did not reach for one. Rosemary Tackett took two.
“It’s a hundred and twelve weeks as of November. The average is four thousand eight hundred and fifty dollars a week. It comes to two hundred and fifty-two thousand dollars a year, and your own shrink codes say the same number. I told the district forty-one times. The ticket numbers are in red.”
She went through it in the order she would have worked a pallet. She told them about the truck that was due at eleven and went to Zanesville first, with the milk loaded in the nose. Boyd Stotts’s date-pull sheets put that at seventy-eight thousand dollars a year. Then she opened the binder to the property file.
“The third thing I never wrote down, because nobody at a store gets to see it. You charge Store #2 three hundred and sixty thousand dollars a year for its building. Hilde Brockmeyer paid that building off in 1978. Your insurance appraisal last year says it’s worth four hundred and ten thousand. So in under fourteen months you bill us the whole price of the place, and then you start over.”
The dentist laughed, once, and covered his mouth.
“You were told in October that my store lost six hundred and forty thousand dollars. Two fifty-two, seventy-eight and three sixty make six hundred and ninety. Take those out, and Store #2 made fifty thousand.”
“That’s one store,” the banker said. He had a soft voice and a sharp pencil. “A particular one, with a particular history.”
“Yes, sir. I thought you’d say so.” She took the folder off the table and opened it. “On November twenty-ninth I asked the night leads at the other twenty-two stores on your list to keep the same record for two weeks. Seventeen did. On Monday I asked those seventeen whether they’d put their names to it. Every one of them said yes before midnight. These are signed. Darlene Hoyt at Store 31 in Caldwell gets thirty cases of bagged salad a week and sells eight. Marcus Lambert at 58 in Gallipolis got eleven cases of kale. Teresa Bird at 64 in Pomeroy has a truck due at half past eleven that has never once landed before ten till two.”
She passed the folder to her left. Annie Brockmeyer opened it and began handing pages down the table.
“In those two weeks, seventeen stores threw out a hundred and thirty-eight thousand four hundred dollars of fresh product at cost. Across a year and all twenty-three, that’s four point nine million. Late routes cost one point six million. The rent on buildings you own is nine point six million. Your slide says those twenty-three stores lost fourteen point seven.”
She let them do the sum. She watched the banker do it with his pencil.
“They made one point four million dollars,” she said. “That’s about a penny on the dollar, and I know that’s thin. But they made it with somebody else’s thumb on the scale, and nobody in those stores was ever told there was a scale.”
It was quiet. She looked at the clock on the wall. She had four minutes left, and she knew what she wanted them for.
“There’s one more thing. Mr. Brockmeyer put it in his report in December without asking me, and I got written up for it, and then he took it out. I’m putting it back in. It’s mine to tell.” She did not look at him. “There’s a coffee can under register 1 at my store. Hilde Brockmeyer put it there in 1962. If you’re short, you sign a card and the can covers you, and you pay when you can. Nobody’s charged a cent of interest, and nobody’s ever been chased. I count it the first of every month. A week ago it had fifteen hundred and thirty-eight dollars in it and twenty-six cards.”
She had counted it herself on New Year’s morning, twice.
“Since 1962 there have been better than nine thousand four hundred cards. All but about three hundred were paid back. That’s ninety-seven percent. I’m telling you so you’ll know what kind of town you’d be closing a store in. They pay what they owe. They just need till the third Wednesday.”
The banker’s pencil had stopped. “Ninety-seven,” he said. “Unsecured, with no term.”
“Yes, sir.”
“I ran a consumer loan book for eleven years. I never saw ninety-seven on paper that had a car behind it.”
“We don’t take cars,” Josie said. “That’s all I have, Mrs. Tackett.”
She sat down. Her knees were not quite steady, and she was glad of the chair.
Dale Kessler had taken his glasses off while she spoke. He put them on again now.
“Ms. Shriver, I heard you in your own back room in December, and I thought then that you were the best thing I saw in twenty-three stores. I think so now. The uniform rate was written in my department in 2011, as you may have been told. It was built to compare stores. It was never built to decide which ones live, and I’ll say for the minutes that it should not have been used that way.” He turned to the others. “But I have to say the rest, and I don’t say it to wound her. On one side this board has statements audited by a firm that has signed them for thirty years. On the other it has a clerk’s notebooks. They are honest notebooks, I believe. They are still a clerk’s notebooks against audited books, and two weeks of seventeen more. We are being asked to turn down three billion dollars on them.”
Josie felt her face go hot. She kept her hands flat on the table.
“Dale, I’d like a question before anybody answers that,” Rosemary Tackett said. She had the ninth notebook open in front of her, and she had not lost the place. “Ms. Shriver. What’s your shrink on bagged salad?”
“Eleven percent. That’s since November eighth, when I started writing the order myself. Before that I couldn’t give you a percent that meant anything. Some weeks I threw out more than I sold.”
“Eleven’s high. I’d have fired a produce man over eleven.”
“Yes, ma’am. It ought to be four or five.”
“Then why isn’t it?”
“Because my truck lands at half past one. If it landed at eleven, I’d have the cooler set and take the cold in a pallet at a time. At half past one I’ve got four and a half hours to put up the whole load, so all the cold goes in together, and that cooler door stands open forty minutes. The salad’s been on the trailer since supper. Then it sits in a box that’s climbed to forty-three degrees. Bagged lettuce loses two days in a night like that. The order’s right now. The eleven that’s left is the truck.”
“Can you show me the truck?”
“I’ve written the landing time every night for two years. Appendix C in the third binder is Heath’s own gate stamps and the driver’s delivery scans. They match my book to within four minutes, every night. I checked them all.”
Rosemary turned to Appendix C. She ran her finger down a column and then down a page of the notebook. She did it for three different weeks. Nobody spoke while she did it.
“Dale,” she said, “I ran nine stores for twenty-six years, and I hired every produce manager I ever had. I never had one who could tell me her salad shrink to the percent, and what it should be, and which forty minutes of the night it comes from. And she’s got the warehouse’s own clock to back her. That isn’t a clerk’s notebook. It’s the best operating record this company owns, and we closed it forty-one times with two words.” She shut the binder. “Your audited books told us what those stores lost, and they were accurate. They couldn’t tell us why. She can. Mr. Brockmeyer, you said you’d be short.”
Leo stayed in his chair.
“I approved the ordering system in August of 2024. I’ve signed three statements that carried the occupancy charge. I’ve checked every figure Ms. Shriver gave you against our own ledgers, and they hold. I got this wrong from that chair for three and a half years. She got it right from a receiving desk. I vote no. That’s all I have.”
It had taken him about twenty seconds. He had not looked at her while he said it. He had looked at each of the six others in turn.
“Then I’ll call it,” Rosemary said. “The motion is to accept the offer. It needs four. Mr. Kessler.”
“Yes,” Dale said. “A penny on the dollar is still a penny, and sixteen weeks’ pay is certain. I’ve seen the other thing.”
“Mr. Mendel.”
The banker laid his pencil down. “I’ve never seen forty-one times earnings, and my duty is to the people who own the shares. Yes. I’ll add that I’m less comfortable than I was at nine o’clock.”
“Mrs. Lutz.”
The woman with the long jaw had a signed log in front of her. It was Darlene’s, in pencil. She had read it to the bottom.
“I’m still tired,” she said. “My brother’s still dead. Yes. But I’m glad I was made to hear it, Leo.”
That was three. Josie put her right hand over her left, on top of the count.
“Ms. Brockmeyer.”
“No,” Annie said.
“Mr. Brockmeyer has voted no. Dr. Lutz.”
The dentist looked at his mother. She did not look back at him. He closed the first notebook and laid both hands on its cover.
“We’ve been charging them rent on a building Grandma paid off, and sending them kale,” he said. “I can explain that to my hygienists in one sentence. I couldn’t explain a yes to them at all. No. Sorry, Mom.”
“Don’t be sorry,” his mother said. “You sound like your uncle.”
Three and three. Josie could hear the clock.
Rosemary Tackett took her glasses off and looked down the table, past all of them, at the photograph on the wall.
“I closed a store once that I still think about,” she said. “I’m not adding twenty-three to it. The chair votes no. That’s three in favor and four against. The motion fails, and the offer is declined.”
Nobody cheered. It was not that kind of room. Annie put her hand over her eyes. The dentist blew out his breath. Josie sat very still. She thought of Boyd at the corkboard working out five days a year, and of Hazel, who would be sitting up by May in a town that still had a store. She found she had to look at the notebooks for a moment before she could look at anything else.
“I have a second motion,” Leo said, “if the chair will take it.”
“Go ahead.”
“Three parts. One. Every store under twenty-five thousand square feet sets its own caps on fresh orders, beginning with next Sunday’s order, written by whoever the store says knows the town. Two. No occupancy charge on any building the company owns, effective with this fiscal year, and the last three years’ store statements restated to show it. Three. Every officer of this company works one full shift a month in a store, on the floor, under the lead on duty. That begins with me, and it includes nights.”
“Second,” said Annie.
Rosemary called it down the table. The dentist said yes. Annie said yes. The banker said that the occupancy note should never have got past an audit committee he sat on, and yes. Ingrid Lutz said she was sixty-three and was not stocking shelves, and Leo said directors were exempt, and she said yes, then.
“Mr. Kessler.”
Dale had been reading the motion over in his own handwriting. “I told the chairman in a parking lot that I’d be glad to be shown,” he said. “I have been. Yes.”
“And the chair. Seven to nothing. We’re adjourned.”
Chairs rolled back. Rosemary Tackett came down the length of the table with the ninth notebook held in both hands. She gave it back open to the right page.
“I asked him to bring me one to hold,” she said. “I’d like to come and see that salad case sometime.”
“We open at six, ma’am. I’m there before that.”
“I’ll be there at five.”
The others were moving toward the door. Leo had not left the head of the table. He stood there with his hand on the back of his chair, sixty feet of polished wood away, and he made no move to come down it. She had told him she was not doing this for him. He seemed to mean to let her go on not having done it for him.
She began putting the notebooks back in the sack. A camel overcoat stopped beside her.
Dale Kessler had his hat in his left hand. He held out his right.
“Ms. Shriver. I voted against you, and I’d do it again on what I knew at nine o’clock. I want you to know I didn’t enjoy that sentence about clerks.”
“You said it kindly enough. And you weren’t wrong that I’m a clerk.”
“I was wrong about what one can know.” His grip was dry and firm. He looked down at her hand in his, at the ink on the back of it, and he very nearly smiled. “Last night’s count?”
“Eleven hundred and forty. It landed at 1:32.”
“Of course it did.” He let go. “My father had seven hardware stores, a long time ago. He lost them all in a week. He never had anyone who wrote things down.” He put his hat on. “My father would have hired you.”
“He’d have had to pay me fair,” Josie said.
“He would have,” Dale said. “It might have saved him.”
***