Chapter 2 of 26
Twelve Weeks
13 min · 3,239 words
His grandmother watched the whole meeting from the wall.
The portrait at the end of the boardroom was the 1962 photograph, the one on every jar of Hilde’s Own apple butter: Hilde Brockmeyer at thirty-one in a white grocer’s apron, standing in front of a plate-glass window with her arms crossed and her chin up. Leo had grown up under that look, and it had never once let him off easy.
He sat at the head of the table with a cup of coffee he had not touched. It was 9:04 on Thursday morning, the fifteenth of October, and Dale Kessler was on his feet.
“I’ll be brief,” Dale said. He was not a brief man, but he was a clear one. He had been chief financial officer for twenty-six years before he took the vice chairman’s seat, and he stood at the screen like a man who had never been caught out by a number. He was sixty-four, with a silver crew cut and rimless glasses, and a voice that did not need to be raised. “Ashgrove Capital Partners of Chicago has offered three billion dollars in cash for one hundred percent of Brockmeyer’s Markets. You’ve all had the letter since Monday. Here is what it means.”
The slide changed.
“We earned seventy-three million dollars last year on sales of five point six billion. Ashgrove is offering forty-one times that. Gordon can tell you how often a regional grocer sees forty-one times earnings.”
“Never,” Gordon Mendel said from halfway down the table. He was sixty-six, a retired Columbus banker with a soft voice and a hard pencil. “I’ve been in this business forty years, and I have never seen it.”
“The offer is open until Friday, January fifteenth. After that it’s withdrawn.” Dale clicked again. “Now the part nobody will enjoy. Ashgrove’s operating plan closes the twenty-three smallest stores within a hundred and twenty days of the sale. That’s one thousand four hundred and sixty jobs. The buildings would be sold. Every one of those employees would receive sixteen weeks’ severance.”
“Sixteen,” said Rosemary Tackett. “That’s generous, for private equity.”
“It is. I asked for it.” Dale did not explain, and he went on. “Those twenty-three stores are the ones that lose money, and they have lost money for years. The list is in your packet in order of size. I’ll put up the first one, because I think we owe it to the name on the building to look straight at it.”
The slide read Store #2, New Galway, Ohio.
Leo kept his hands flat on the table.
“Opened June 2, 1962. Eighteen thousand five hundred square feet. Thirty-four employees. Sales last year of seven point nine million.” Dale paused. “And a loss of six hundred and forty thousand dollars. That’s the oldest store we still operate. It was Hilde’s own, and she ran it herself for eight years. I knew her for a quarter of a century, and I’ll tell you what she’d say about a store that lost six hundred and forty thousand dollars.”
“You don’t know what she’d say,” Annie said.
Leo’s sister sat on his left in a navy sweater, with her hospital lanyard still around her neck because she had come straight off a night in the pediatric ER in Columbus. She was thirty-one and held eleven percent of the company, and she had never in her life let Dale Kessler finish a thought about their grandmother.
“Perhaps not,” Dale said mildly. “I know what her books said. She closed the Coshocton store herself in 1981 when it stopped paying. She cried, and then she closed it.”
“She wrote the bylaws so that people like Ashgrove couldn’t just buy us,” Annie said.
“She wrote the bylaws so that seven people would have to look each other in the eye first. That’s what we’re doing.” Dale took off his glasses and polished them on his tie. “I’m not selling anybody’s birthright out from under them. I own five percent of this company. The Brockmeyers and the Lutzes own seventy-nine. I’m telling you what I see. I see a chain that makes a penny and a third on the dollar in a business where the big boys are coming for us from both sides. I see twenty-three stores bleeding. And I see somebody offering to pay us for all of it before it gets worse, and to send fourteen hundred and sixty people home with four months’ pay instead of nothing. I’ve seen what nothing looks like. I’d take the sixteen weeks.”
He sat down. The room was quiet.
Leo’s aunt spoke first. Ingrid Lutz was sixty-three, his father’s younger sister, with Stefan’s long jaw and none of his patience. She owned twenty-four percent.
“I’ll say it, since no one else will. I’m tired, Leo. Your father worked himself into the ground for this company, and I watched him do it. I’d like to know what it’s like to own something that doesn’t call you at midnight.” She turned her wedding ring on her finger. “I lean yes. I’m sorry.”
“You don’t have to be sorry, Aunt Ingrid.”
“I am anyway.”
“I lean yes,” Gordon said. “I’m an independent director. My job is to tell the shareholders when the price is right, and the price is right.”
“No,” Annie said. “Obviously.”
Dale inclined his head. “And I’m yes. That’s three and one. Mr. Chairman?”
Leo looked down the table. Under the 1994 bylaws there were seven directors with one vote each, and the size of a director’s stake did not come into it. He held thirty-five percent of the company. At Ashgrove’s price that was a billion and fifty million dollars, a number he had typed into a cell on Monday night and then deleted, because he did not like how long he had looked at it. On this question his thirty-five percent counted exactly as much as his cousin’s nine.
“No,” he said. “But I want to say why, and it isn’t sentiment.” He nodded at the screen. “Dale, I don’t believe that number.”
Dale’s eyebrows went up a careful quarter inch. “It’s audited.”
“I know it’s audited. I signed the audit. I’m saying I’ve been in that chair for three and a half years, and I can tell you what Store #2 lost. I can’t tell you why. I can’t tell you why for any of the twenty-three. I came here from nine years of corporate finance in Chicago, and I have run this company the way I was trained to, from the top of a spreadsheet down. I’ve approved systems I never watched anybody use. I’ve been inside maybe forty of our hundred and sixty-four stores, and always at ten in the morning with a district manager walking in front of me.” He heard how that sounded, and he let it stand. “A store in a town of twenty-four hundred people did seven point nine million in sales. People are shopping there. So where does the money go?”
“Small stores cost more to run,” Gordon said. “That’s arithmetic.”
“Maybe so. Then I’ll find that out, and I’ll tell you so.”
Rosemary Tackett put down her pen. She was sixty-nine, the other independent, a broad, plain-spoken woman who had built nine grocery stores in eastern Kentucky and sold them in 2012 for a price she still would not discuss.
“I’ll tell you where I am,” she said. “I’ve closed stores. Two of them. One deserved it and one I still think about. A store that size, in a town with no competition for eleven miles, doing eight million? That ought to make a little money. It’s not much, but it ought to make some. So either those folks down there can’t run a store, or something up here is being done to them. I don’t know which. I’m not voting to put fourteen hundred people out until somebody shows me.”
“Toby?” Dale said.
Leo’s cousin had been sitting very still, as he probably did while a patient’s X-rays came up. Toby Lutz was thirty-eight, a dentist in Lancaster, and he held the nine percent his mother had given him in 2018. He glanced at Ingrid before he answered, which Leo noticed, and then he seemed to make himself stop.
“I fill teeth,” Toby said. “I don’t know groceries. Mom thinks we should sell, and Mom’s usually right. But it’s two hundred and seventy million dollars to me, and it’s somebody’s job to them, and I’d like to be able to explain my vote to my hygienists.” He shrugged, embarrassed. “I’m with Rosemary. Show me something.”
So it was three leaning yes and two no, with two waiting to be convinced.
“Then here’s what I’m asking for,” Leo said. “Ashgrove’s offer runs to January fifteenth. Give me twelve weeks. Set the vote for Friday, January eighth, ten o’clock, in this room. That’s a full week inside their deadline. I’ll bring the board whatever I find about those twenty-three stores, and if what I find says Dale’s right, I’ll say so on the record.”
“And where will you be finding it?” Dale asked.
“In the field.”
“That covers a great deal of ground.”
“It’s meant to.” Leo met his eyes. “Paulette and the operating committee have the day-to-day. I’ll be on every Monday call. You’ll have my phone.”
Dale studied him for a long moment. In that same look, when Leo was nine, Dale had worked out who had been at the petty cash in his father’s desk. Then he put his glasses back on.
“Twelve weeks is fair,” he said. “I’d rather win this on the facts than on a clock. January eighth, ten a.m. So moved.”
“Second,” Rosemary said.
It carried without objection. Chairs rolled back. Ingrid came around the table and kissed Leo’s cheek. “You look like a lumberjack,” she said. “Shave before Christmas.” Then she was gone, with Toby behind her mouthing sorry.
Dale stopped at the door.
“Leopold. For what it’s worth, I hope you find something. I’d like to be wrong about the old store.” He nodded up at the portrait. “I don’t think I am.”
“I know you don’t.”
“Twelve weeks,” Dale said, and he left.
Annie caught up with Leo in the corridor outside, under the row of framed store photographs, and steered him by the elbow into the stairwell.
“Okay,” she said. “Talk fast, I’ve been up nineteen hours. Is it done?”
“It’s done. Paulette put it through yesterday afternoon.”
“Say it to me like I’m checking your wristband.”
He almost smiled. “Leo Fisher. Night stocker, Store #2, New Galway. Fifteen seventy-five an hour. Sunday through Thursday nights, ten to six-thirty. I start tonight.”
“Fisher. Mom’s going to love that.”
“It’s the only other name I’ll answer to without thinking.”
“Who knows?”
“You and Paulette. That’s all. The paperwork went from her desk straight to the store manager, so the district never touched it. The file has a real application and a real reference. I’m told I did the numbers for a food company in Chicago and got tired of an office.”
“That’s almost true.”
“That’s why I picked it.”
Annie leaned back against the cinder-block wall and looked him over, from the beard he had been growing since August down to his shoes. He was six foot one, and she had been looking at him as if he were shorter since she was four.
“The beard’s good,” she admitted. “You look like a youth pastor. Nobody down there has ever seen you?”
“I’ve never set foot in the building. I was supposed to go for the sixtieth anniversary, and Dad’s heart thing happened that week. The only picture of me the stores get is the one in the annual letter, and I’m clean-shaven and wearing a tie and standing next to a pyramid of oranges.”
“You look twelve in that picture.”
“Thank you.”
“The badge?”
“It just says LEO. That’s how they do them.”
She was quiet for a second. Down the corridor somebody laughed, and a copier started up.
“Can I say the thing?” she said.
“You’re going to.”
“These are real people. They aren’t a case study. You’re going to stand next to them all night for three months, and they’re going to tell you about their kids and their backs and their truck payments, because that’s what people do at four in the morning. I know, I work at four in the morning. And every single thing you say back is going to have a hole in it.”
“I’m going there to stock shelves and read invoices, Annie.”
“Uh-huh.”
“I’m going to find out why a store with customers loses six hundred and forty thousand dollars. Then I’m coming back here and telling seven people. I’m not going to make friends.”
“You make friends with parking attendants.” She pushed off the wall and hugged him hard, the lanyard digging into his chest. “Don’t make one you have to lie to, Leo. That’s all. If you start to, tell them or leave. Promise me.”
“I promise.”
“Text me when you get there. And eat something that isn’t a granola bar.”
She went down the stairs. He stood there a moment longer with the promise in his mouth, and it had been very easy to say.
He left Newark at two. His own car stayed in the garage at his house. What he drove out of the support-center lot was a 2013 Subaru, dark green, with a hundred and forty thousand miles on it and a smell of wet dog he had not been able to shift. He had paid $8,900 cash for it eight days earlier, to a man in Heath who had counted the bills twice and asked no questions. In the back were two duffel bags, a laptop, a box of kitchen things and a pair of work boots still in their box.
It was sixty-three miles, about an hour and twenty minutes: east to Zanesville, then south on State Route 60 with the Muskingum on his left the whole way down. He had not driven it since he was a boy in the back of his grandmother’s Buick. The hills were at the top of their color, red and rust and a yellow so bright it looked lit from inside, and the river ran wide and brown and slow between them. He passed the old locks and a hand-painted sign for sorghum. He passed through McConnelsville, with its opera house on the square. Eleven miles later a green sign said NEW GALWAY, POP. 2,400, and under it, on a smaller board the Lions Club must have put up, HOME OF THE FIRST BROCKMEYER’S STILL STANDING.
He slowed down to read that twice.
Front Street was four blocks long and ran along the river wall. There was a bank, a diner and a hardware store. The post office had a flag out front. A brick building had MUSKINGUM DRUG in gold leaf on the window, and the window was papered over from inside. That was 114. The key was in an envelope taped inside the street door, as the landlord had said it would be, along with a note that the radiator knocked and would he please not report it.
The two rooms were at the top of a narrow staircase. There was a front room with a tall window over the street, a bed, a table and the radiator, which was already knocking, and a kitchen at the back the size of his office closet. The rent was $700 a month. He had signed for it by mail as L. Fisher and sent a money order.
He put the duffels on the bed and stood at the window. The river was right there across the street, with the far hills going blue behind it. A woman on the sidewalk below was walking a beagle. She looked up at the window with open interest, and he understood that by suppertime the whole town would know somebody had taken the rooms over the drugstore.
He texted Annie: Here. It has a radiator with opinions.
She sent back a thumbs-up and a sandwich.
He ate at the diner, a hot roast beef plate for $9.50, and the waitress asked where he was from and he said Chicago, most recently. That was true, and he could feel the hole in it. He tried to sleep from five to eight and mostly lay looking at the pressed-tin ceiling. At nine he got up, showered, and put on jeans and a grey thermal shirt and the boots. They were stiff as planks. He laced them in the dark, because the bulb in the front room had turned out to be dead.
The store was half a mile away. He drove it anyway, since he did not yet know what he would feel like at 6:30 in the morning.
Riverside Drive climbed a little as it left town, and Store #2 sat at the top of the rise in a lot that looked down on the water. He had seen the building in photographs all his life. It was low and tan, with a flat roof and a red band along the top, and the old script sign that the company had replaced everywhere else forty years ago. A few cars were left in the lot. The plate-glass window from the portrait was still there, to the right of the doors. The same glass had probably been replaced, he told himself, but it was the same window.
His grandmother had stood right there in a white apron and crossed her arms at the camera. She had been four years younger than he was now.
He parked at the far end, the way Paulette’s instructions said employees did, and walked around the building to the back. There was a concrete dock, a dumpster, a stack of milk crates and a steel door under a caged light. A sign on the door said RECEIVING. RING BELL. He looked at his phone. It was 9:52.
He rang the bell.
It was a long half minute. He had time to notice that his hands were cold and that he was nervous. That struck him as ridiculous. He had sat across from Ashgrove’s lawyers without his pulse changing. But he had known what he was doing in that room. He was about to walk into a building with his name on it, and he did not know how to do any job there was to do inside.
The door opened outward and he stepped back.
The woman holding it was a head shorter than he was and did not seem to know it. She wore a red work vest over a long-sleeved shirt pushed up to the elbows, and a red Brockmeyer’s cap with dark hair knotted up under it. There was a box cutter clipped to her pocket and a number written in ink on the back of her hand. Her eyes were brown and direct, and they took him in from the top down in about two seconds, the way she probably looked over a pallet to see what was wrong with it.
They stopped at his feet.
He had the sentence ready. Hi, I’m Leo, I’m supposed to start tonight. He had practiced it in the car, and now he did not get to use it.
“You’re Fisher?” she said. “Your boots still have the tag on.”
***