The Milsom Street Ledger 2 / 26
Size
Spacing
Page
Type

Chapter 2 of 26

The Figure Thirteen

12 min · 3,061 words

The summons had said eleven o’clock on Wednesday at No. 19 Royal Crescent, and Eleanor was at the door at ten minutes to the hour with her aunt on her arm.

“You need only say what you saw and what the clock said,” Aunt Marrable whispered for the fourth time since Milsom Street. “Nobody can think the worse of you for that. A lady may be summoned. It is not like going of one’s own will.”

“No, Aunt.”

“And you will not put yourself forward.”

Eleanor did not answer that. The knocker was tied up in black crape, and the footman who let them in had red eyes.

They had set the inquest in the dining room. The long table was pushed to the wall with the coroner behind it, a dry, elderly attorney with a clerk at his elbow. Fifteen Bath householders sat in two rows of my lady’s dining chairs to make the jury, and they had the pinched look of men who had just been taken upstairs to view a body. Eleanor knew nine of them by their handwriting. Mr. Gillard the hatter was among them and gave her a troubled nod.

The family sat by the window. Mrs. Prideaux was in deep black, her face very white inside her bonnet and a handkerchief folded small in her gloved hand. Her husband sat beside her, a tall, stooping clergyman of four-and-fifty with a gentle, bewildered face. Behind them was Miss Tolley, the companion, thin as a rail in an old black silk; her right hand shook in her lap and she held it down with her left. Captain Ashe stood against the wall with his arms folded. He did not look as if he had slept.

Bridget stood by the sideboard between a city constable and a gaoler’s man. They had let her keep her own gown, and she held her wrists together in front of her as though she had already grown used to irons. She looked once at Eleanor and then fixed her eyes on the carpet.

Eleanor sat down at the back with her aunt and folded her hands so that the ink stain did not show.

Nancy Webb, the housemaid, was sworn first. She was twenty-eight and stout, and she cried the whole time she spoke.

“I come down the main stairs at seven, sir, to do the hall grate. It was dark still. I had my candle. And she was lying at the bottom with her head on the last step and her feet up the stairs, in her nightgown and her wrapper. Her candlestick was by her on the floor, the silver one from her night table. I touched her hand and it was stone cold.”

“You knew she was dead?”

“Her neck was wrong, sir.” Nancy put her apron to her mouth. “I screamed for James.”

A surgeon followed her and said in a dozen words that the neck was broken, that death had been immediate, and that it had come some hours before the finding, most likely near midnight. Then the coroner asked whether Mrs. Prideaux felt equal to it, and Mrs. Prideaux said in her soft voice that she did.

She gave her evidence sitting, at the coroner’s wish. She had dined with her mother on Monday at six, with Miss Tolley and her cousin Captain Ashe. Captain Ashe had left at half past seven for the ball. She herself had stayed until a quarter to ten and had been lighted home to Brock Street by the footman, a walk of two minutes. Her mother had been in good health and good spirits, and had worn her diamonds at dinner.

“Describe them, if you please, ma’am, for the jury.”

“A rivière, sir. A single row of forty-one brilliants, the largest at the clasp. My late father gave it to her on their marriage in 1766. It was valued in London in 1811 at six thousand pounds.”

A sound went along the two rows of chairs. Six thousand pounds was more than most of those men would handle in their lives.

“And it was to leave the house on Tuesday?”

“A jeweller’s man was to come from London for it. My mother meant it for my daughter.” Mrs. Prideaux pressed the handkerchief to her lips for a moment. “James fetched me at a quarter past seven on Tuesday morning. When I had seen Mama, I went up to her dressing room with Miss Tolley. The red morocco case was on the bureau, open and empty. The bureau was unlocked, with Mama’s chatelaine hanging from the keyhole by its key. She kept the chatelaine on her night table. She never let it out of her reach.”

“Who locked the necklace away on Monday night?”

Mrs. Prideaux hesitated. She looked, with what seemed real pain, towards the sideboard. “Her maid, sir. It was always her maid.”

Miss Tolley was asked only whether she agreed with that account. She said, in a thread of a voice, that she did; that she had read to my lady in bed for a while and left her settled; and that she had heard nothing in the night, for her room was at the back. Her hand shook so that the Testament slipped when she kissed it, and the clerk caught it.

James Hobday, the footman, swore that he had bolted the front door and the area door at eleven o’clock and gone to his bed. He said it quickly, with his eyes on the coroner’s inkstand. The coroner wrote down that the house had been made fast at eleven.

Then the cook was sworn. Martha Dunn was fifty-two, square and grey, and she came in from the hall with her hands folded on her apron.

“I sleep off the kitchen, sir. I was abed by ten. Something woke me, I don’t know what. The kitchen clock had struck the half hour after eleven a little before, ten minutes it might be. Then I heard my lady cry out, up above. One word.”

“What word?”

“‘Bridie!’ Sharp, like she was angry or frightened. Then there was a fall. A heavy sound, and something rolling.”

“You are sure of the voice?”

“I’ve cooked for her fifteen years, sir. I’d know it in my grave.”

“And you did not get up?”

Martha Dunn’s face worked. “I thought Bridie had dropped something, and my lady was calling out at her. I listened, and it was all quiet. I’d been up since five with a dinner to send up. I went back to sleep, God forgive me.”

“Tell the jury what you found in the morning.”

“I rose at six to light the range. I went along the back passage for the coal and I saw the garden door. The bolt was drawn. That door’s bolted every night of the year. It gives on the garden and the garden gives on the lane.”

Eleanor looked at Bridget. Bridget had lifted her head at the word “Bridie” and was staring at the cook with her lips parted, like a woman who has been struck by a friend.

The constable came last of the household’s witnesses, a heavy, careful man who read from a pocket-book.

“I was fetched at half past seven. I saw the deceased, the case, and the garden door. Mrs. Prideaux said to me, very properly, that the servants’ boxes and things had best be looked through at once, for their own sakes, so that nobody honest need lie under suspicion. I began at the bottom of the house. Beside the garden door is the drying room, and by that a row of pegs. On the second peg hung a woman’s grey cloak. In the pocket I found these.”

He laid two things on the table. One was a white handkerchief, knotted. He undid the knot, and something small in it took the light from the window and threw it back.

“One stone, loose. Mrs. Prideaux knew it for the clasp stone of the necklace. The handkerchief is marked B.C. in red thread. The prisoner owns to the cloak and the handkerchief both. This paper was folded under them.”

“Read it.”

The constable held it at arm’s length. “‘Bristol, the Bush, Wednesday’s first coach. Ask for Mr. Dwyer, who settles all. Bring them sewn in your stays.’ It is signed with a letter B.”

Nobody in the room spoke. Mr. Prideaux had shut his eyes. Captain Ashe said something under his breath that was not fit for a dining room.

“The necklace itself?”

“Not found, sir, in the house or the garden. I take it that it went out by that door.”

“Call Miss Fairley.”

Aunt Marrable gripped her wrist and let it go. Eleanor walked up between the chairs, feeling the eyes of fifteen subscribers on her back, and took the oath in a voice that came out steadier than she expected.

“You keep the circulating library in Milsom Street.”

“I do, sir. Fairley’s, at No. 27.”

“The prisoner says she was at your counter on Monday night.”

“She was. She came in at twenty-five minutes past eight and took out the third volume of ‘The Antiquary’ for Lady Penhallow. She signed for it. I wrote the hour beside her name, as we do for every loan after six. The ledger is in my shop and any gentleman may see it.”

“How did she seem?”

“As she always seems. She was cheerful and in a hurry. She said she was going on to the apothecary for her mistress’s drops.”

The coroner turned his pen in his fingers. “Did she speak of the diamonds?”

Eleanor had lain awake on this question. She was on her oath, and there was only one answer. “She did. She said my lady was wearing them that night because they were going away next day. She said the stone at the clasp was loose and she was afraid of its dropping out when she put them in their case.”

It went along the jury like wind through wheat. She saw Mr. Gillard look down at his hat.

“So she knew the hour of their going, and she knew that stone was loose. Thank you, Miss Fairley. You may stand down.”

“May I see the note, sir?”

The coroner looked at her over his spectacles. “For what purpose?”

“I have seen the prisoner’s handwriting most weeks for four years. I should like to tell the jury whether that is it.”

“You were summoned as to an hour, ma’am, and you have spoken to it.”

“Let her look, Mr. Coroner,” said Mr. Gillard from the front row. He was pink, but he went on. “I’ve signed that young lady’s book twenty years, and her father’s before. If she says she knows a hand, she knows it.”

The coroner breathed out through his nose and pushed the paper across the table with one finger.

Eleanor took her own spectacles from her reticule and put them on. It was a half sheet of common letter paper, folded twice. The writing stood bolt upright, each letter made slowly, and the ink was good and black. She read it through once for the words and then again for the pen.

There were four capital B’s in it, in Bristol and Bush and Bring and the one that stood alone at the foot. Each was made the same way. The pen had gone down for the stem and come up again and round into the two bows without lifting and without closing them back against the upright, so that the letter stood open and looked like the figure 13 written in haste.

“This is not Bridget Carney’s writing,” she said.

“You are positive?”

“I am, sir. She was taught by nuns in Cork. Her hand is round and it leans a little back. She makes her capital B with a loop at the top of the stem, where the pen turns, and she closes both bows. She has never made it otherwise in my book. Whoever wrote this makes a B in one stroke, like a one and a three together. They did it four times here and did not vary once. A person can hold a pen upright to disguise the slope, but it is hard to change the way one makes a letter, and harder still to keep it up four times running.”

The coroner took the paper back. He did not look at the B’s. “You are a judge of handwriting, Miss Fairley? You have studied it?”

“I have watched two hundred people sign their names across my counter every week since I was fourteen.”

“Just so. You have watched it done.” He laid the note down. “The jury will observe that nobody has said the prisoner wrote this paper. It is signed B. It tells some woman to bring certain things sewn in her stays. Whether the prisoner wrote it to a confederate or had it from one, it was in her cloak pocket, and it was wrapped with a stone from her mistress’s necklace in a handkerchief with her mark. I do not see that the shape of a letter alters that.”

“Then who is B, sir?” Eleanor heard her own voice go up and brought it down. “If it was written to her, a confederate has signed with her initial, and that makes no sense. If she wrote it, the hand should be hers, and it is not. Somebody else held that pen. Should the jury not ask who?”

“The jury will ask what the law requires of them, ma’am. Stand down.”

She stood down. Her knees were not quite her own on the way back to her chair, and her aunt’s face was the colour of the tablecloth. Mrs. Prideaux, by the window, turned her head and gave Eleanor a small, sad, gracious look, as one gives to a child who has meant well.

The coroner told Bridget that she need say nothing, and that anything she said would be written down.

“I’ll say it, sir.” Her voice was hoarse, and Cork was strong in it. “I never wrote that paper and I never saw it till the constable held it under my nose. I never tied any stone in my handkerchief. I came in by the garden door at five past nine on Monday and I bolted it after me, the way I do every night. I undressed my lady and I locked her diamonds in their case with every stone in them. I left her alive in her bed, and I went up to my own and slept. I’d have cut my hand off before I hurt her.”

“You heard the cook swear your mistress cried your name.”

“I heard her.” Bridget looked at Martha Dunn, and the cook looked away. “I can’t tell you what Martha heard, sir. I wasn’t there.”

The jury did not leave the room. They put their heads together in their two rows for a quarter of an hour by the mantel clock, while the fire ticked and Miss Tolley’s hand rattled the beads on her reticule. Eleanor watched Mr. Gillard argue in a whisper, shake his head, and argue again. Then he sat back with his chin on his neckcloth, and the foreman stood up.

“We find that Ursula, Lady Penhallow came by her death on the night of the thirteenth of January by a fall on her own stairs, caused in the course of a robbery. We find a verdict of wilful murder against Bridget Carney.”

Aunt Marrable made a small sound. Eleanor sat perfectly still and watched the clerk write it down.

The coroner signed his warrant. The prisoner was committed to the city gaol in Grove Street, to be held there until she was removed to the county gaol at Ilchester and tried at the Lent Assizes at Taunton. He said it in the same voice in which he had asked about the coal. Theft from a dwelling house was a hanging matter by itself, and murder left no room for mercy at all. Every person in that dining room knew it, and Bridget Carney knew it best of any of them.

The room broke up into black coats and low voices. Mr. Prideaux was helping his wife to her feet. She paused beside Eleanor’s chair on her way to the door.

“It was good of you to try, Miss Fairley,” she said gently. “It does you credit. But you must not distress yourself. These people are not always what they seem to us across a counter.”

“She is exactly what she seems to me, ma’am.”

Mrs. Prideaux pressed her hand and passed on.

In the hall the gaoler’s man had Bridget by the elbow. The front door stood open on the grey sweep of the Crescent, and a plain cart was waiting on the cobbles with a boy holding the horse. Eleanor went straight through the knot of jurymen with her aunt pulling at her sleeve.

“Bridget.”

Bridget turned. She had held herself straight through the whole of it, and she was holding herself straight now, but her freckles stood out like ink on paper.

“I make my B the way the sisters taught me, miss.”

“I know you do. I have it in writing.”

“They didn’t want it.”

“The coroner didn’t.” Eleanor put her hand over Bridget’s cold ones, in front of the constable and the footman and half the tradesmen of Bath. “I shall come to Grove Street on Saturday, and I shall bring you something to read. Keep your hood up in that cart.”

The man moved her on. Eleanor stood on the top step and watched the cart go down towards Brock Street until it turned out of sight.

“My dear,” Aunt Marrable said faintly behind her, “you held her hand. Everyone saw.”

“I hope they did, Aunt.”

She took her aunt’s arm and started down the hill towards Milsom Street. Somewhere in Bath there was a person who made a capital B like the figure 13, and that person had put a rope round Bridget Carney’s neck with it. The coroner had not cared to look, and the jury had looked and been afraid to say what they saw. Eleanor meant to find someone who would look, and until she did, she would go on looking herself.
***

Next · Chapter 3 of 26 · 12 min

A Guinea a Day

Keep reading →

Suggestion slip

Tell the librarian

A book request, a typo, a bug, or just hello.