Chapter 15 of 26
Five to Four
12 min · 3,114 words
Bo Lindgren had a county road map spread across the back workbench, with a socket on each corner to hold it flat.
It was ten to five on Tuesday, the day after Labor Day, and the shop was nearly swept. Leif stood beside him and looked at the yellow. Bo had gone over every ranch road between Whitewood and Nemo with a highlighter, and there were a great many of them. Beside some he had pencilled a small X.
“What’s the X?”
“A roof big enough to matter. Machine sheds, pole barns, an old sawmill.” Bo capped the highlighter. “There are forty-three. I’ll say it at the table.”
Nate had come up with the push broom and stopped at the end of the bench. He was looking at the bottom of the map, where the yellow ran out toward Nemo.
“You hauled for Elk Creek,” Leif said. “You’d have been on half of these.”
“Some.” Nate’s eyes came up off the paper. “Mostly it was road jobs. You’re loaded, and you’re watching the tailgate in front of you. You don’t look at much.”
“You’d notice a place with trucks going in at night,” Bo said, without turning his head. It was the longest thing he had said to Nate in eleven days.
“I drove days.” Nate leaned the broom in its corner. He took his gloves off and folded them into his back pocket, and then took them out and folded them the other way. “It’s five, boss. Hal wants the phone answered.”
“Go on.”
He went. Leif heard the pickup start in the lot and pull out, a good deal more gently than it used to. He thought the map had made the boy uneasy, and he put it down to Bo, who made the boy uneasy every day.
***
Nine men sat at the pine table at seven, with the big door rolled shut against the first cool evening of the fall. Ike was on the step with Spoke and a jacket.
Leif gave them Pam Fenske’s news first. She had phoned at four, and he had written it on a paper bag.
“Three things,” he said. “The first is the trailers. Every port of entry in South Dakota has High Line Moto Transport on a list, and Wyoming came on as of Friday. If one of his rigs rolls across a scale in either state, it gets its doors opened and its paperwork read. He knows it. He hasn’t sent a truck through since the two they stopped.”
“So he can’t haul them out,” Tommy Aune said.
“He can’t haul them out under his own name. The second thing is the man himself. Garrett Lusk has rented a house on Williams Street in Deadwood, up above Main. The lease is paid through the end of October. He’s got a company in Denver, and he’s living fourteen miles from this table.”
Hank Sorensen took his cap off and looked into it.
“The third is the bikes. Sixty-one went in ten days. Pam has three, the same three she had on the seventeenth of August. She’s had the numbers out to every salvage yard and auction house in six states for three weeks. No frame has turned up, and no motor, and no fairing.” He laid the bag down. “Nobody steals fifty-eight motorcycles to keep them. If they’d been moved, some would have surfaced by now. They haven’t been moved. They’re still in the Hills, under a roof, and he’s paying rent in Deadwood to sit close to them until everybody stops looking.”
“Then where’s the roof?” Bo said.
He had the map with him. He unrolled it down the middle of the table, and men moved their coffee.
“Three Sundays,” Bo said. “The first one was the twenty-third, and I went with Tommy and didn’t say so here. The last two there were five of us. We’ve driven every one of these yellow roads. There are forty-three buildings on them big enough to hold what we’re talking about. We looked at every one from the county road, and where there was a house we knocked and asked.”
“Asked how?” Dag said.
“Polite. We said we’d had bikes stolen and we were asking everybody. You were there for two of them, Dag. Nobody set foot past a gate without being told to come ahead.”
Dag nodded once.
“And?” Roy said. It was the first word he had spoken.
“Hay. A combine. A man outside Nemo with eleven snowmobiles, who wanted to sell me one.” Bo put his thick forearms down on the map. “Nine of the forty-three had nobody home and a lock on the door. I’ve got those marked. I can’t see through tin, and I’m not allowed to try. So that’s a month, and I’ve got a list of nine padlocks.”
“Give the list to Pam,” Leif said.
“I did. She said thank you.” Bo rolled the map up again, hard. “Everybody says thank you.”
Leif let that sit a moment. Bo had earned it.
Then he told them about Kusler’s. He had asked Hallie at the scale that morning what he could lay on this table, and she had thought it over through a whole board of braids. Tell them what’s been done to my building, she had said. Tell them the date. They sat on my bench for a week, and they’ve earned the date. What I’ve paid and what I haven’t is mine.
So he gave them the brick through the front window in the small hours of the seventeenth, with OCT 1 printed on it. He gave them the grey truck idling at the alley mouth on the twenty-first, and four tires cut on the thirtieth by a man who knew where the camera was. He gave them last Wednesday, when Lusk sat on a stool at her counter and ate a square of kuchen.
“He told her his father’s side,” Leif said. “Wes hung this door. Wes stood up at two weddings. Karl Haugen didn’t sit him down like any other club would have. He said she’d have heard what Karl did, because everybody on that street has.”
Roy and Hank and Curt Bauer had all been at this table in November of 2004. None of them looked at the others.
“We let that story stand,” Roy said quietly. “I said at the time it would come back around.”
“You did. It has.” Leif put his hands flat on the wood. “Here’s what I’m asking, exactly. The first of October is twenty-three days off. Until then I want a vest on her bench in the mornings, as before. I want the alley covered on any night I’m not there. And I want this whole table on Junction Avenue on the day itself, eating pie, where he can count us. The rules are the same. Nobody lays a hand on anyone, and what we see goes to Pam the same hour.”
Nobody spoke. Roy unfolded his reading glasses, looked at them, and folded them again.
“I’ll say my piece,” he said. “It’s about the boy.”
“Go ahead.”
“Nate Kusler is twenty-four. He gambles. By your own account he owes money to Wes Lusk’s son, and he lost a driving job over it in July. On the twenty-eighth of August you put him on the floor of that shop. On the twenty-ninth you gave him the third key there has ever been to the parts loft.” Roy’s voice did not rise. “That shop isn’t only yours, Leif. Arvid fixed it so the garage carries this hut. It pays the lights and the insurance on the Run, and it paid the pantry once when the pantry was robbed. If the garage comes up short, the club comes up short. So I’ve got a gambler with a key, in the shop that pays our bills. He was hired without one word to this table, by a president who sleeps in a bakery.”
Lyle Engstrom shifted in his chair. Pete Dvorak looked at the door.
Leif had been ready for most of that sentence. He had not been ready for how it sounded when someone else said it.
“The payroll’s the garage’s,” he said. “I told you that at the counter, and it’s still so. But you’ve asked a fair question about the man, and I’ll answer it. He’s been on my floor at ten to seven every working day since he started. He counted the loft in three days and found the book wrong. It was wrong in our favour, two stators we didn’t know we had. A thief doesn’t hand you back two stators.”
“He might, the first week,” Curt said.
“He might. On Sunday the thirtieth he came in on his own time and helped me true a wheel, and he’s got better hands than he knows. He backs a trailer cleaner than anybody at this table but Dag. Half his first cheque went to his sister on Friday, before he saw it, and that’s how every cheque will go until she’s paid.” Leif looked down the table at Roy. “He’s working off what he owes, honestly and well. That’s eleven days of it. I’ll tell you the same on the twelfth if it’s true, and I’ll tell you first if it isn’t.”
“And the cash drawer?”
“Locked. I count it. I did before he came.”
Bo was studying the rolled map between his hands.
“He sweeps under things,” Bo said. “I’ll give him that. I don’t have to like him.”
“Nobody asked you to.”
“Good.” Bo looked up. “I’m voting for the alley. I want that understood. Whoever comes to that woman’s door on the first is the nearest I’ve been to my bike in a month. I’m not voting for the kid.”
“It’s understood,” Leif said. “Lyle. You’ve got something.”
Lyle Engstrom was a quiet man who drove a propane truck. He turned his coffee cup a half circle.
“I voted yes in August,” he said. “For a week, you said, through the Sunday. It’s been a month, and now it’s three weeks more. I like her. I like her bread. But my wife’s asking why I eat breakfast on Junction Avenue, and I can’t tell her, and I don’t have a good answer for myself either. Roy’s said what I’d say. I can’t go with you this time.”
“All right,” Leif said. He meant it, and it still went in.
He called the vote.
Five hands went up for it. They were his own, Dag’s, Bo’s, Pete’s and Tommy’s. Four went up against, and they were Roy’s, Hank’s, Curt’s and Lyle’s.
“Five to four,” Leif said. “It carries.”
“It carries,” Roy said. “I’ll take my Thursdays on the bench, the same as before, and I’ll be on that street on the first. Nobody will say I didn’t.” He put his glasses in his shirt pocket and stood, with his scarred hands on the back of his chair. “But hear me, all of you. I think this goes bad. When it does, it won’t land on Leif alone, and it won’t land on her alone. It’ll land on that patch, and on every back that wears it. This town made up its mind about us once on a story with no truth in it. Think what it’ll do with a true one.”
He did not wait for an answer. He rolled the door up himself, and the cold came in.
Leif closed the meeting. Hank and Curt went out together. Lyle stopped beside him as if he would say something, and then only touched the table with two fingers and went on. Dag stayed long enough to stack the cups.
“Five’s enough,” Dag said.
“It’s one.”
“One’s enough.” He went out too.
Leif sat on alone under the curved roof for a few minutes. In ten years he had never carried a vote by a single hand. He had always thought a president who needed to count that closely had already lost something, and he did not think differently tonight.
***
He carried it down the canyon road like a sack of stones.
It was full dark, and the air had an edge. The Road King ran sweetly. He went over it for six minutes, and it was no lighter at the bottom. Roy was not a spiteful man. Roy had been right in 2004, and people had not listened to him then either.
He put the bike at the alley mouth and shut it off. He had not taken three steps up the bricks when he heard the bolt go back.
The camera had told her. The door opened, and the light fell out across the alley, and Hallie stood in it in her apron. She was holding something in a side towel, in both hands, and steam was coming off it.
“Mind your fingers,” she said. “It’s four minutes out of the oven.”
It was a braid. She put it into his hands, towel and all, and the heat came through the cloth.
“It’s half past nine at night,” he said.
“I held a board back. I wanted to see what the deck does when it’s had all day to cool.” She said it lightly, and she did not look at his face for longer than a second. “Sit down. You’re letting my heat out.”
She sat on the back step with her knees up, and he sat beside her. The kitchen was warm at their backs and the night was cold in front. He broke the braid in two. It tore in long soft strands, and the cardamom came up into his face.
He waited for her to ask how it had gone. She picked up her half and blew on it. She told him the Daily Grind had sold four dozen by twenty to nine that morning, and that a college girl had asked whether cardamom was a kind of cinnamon. Then she stopped talking, and ate, and looked down the alley.
She was not going to ask. She had seen his face in the doorway and decided that for herself.
He had kept that table’s business behind his teeth for ten years. Karl had kept it for thirteen before him. Roy had sat across a breakfast table from Marlys for forty years and never carried one word home, and Marlys had never asked. It was no law, but it was older in him than most of the laws.
“I carried it by one vote,” he said.
She turned her head.
“Five to four. In August it was six to three. Lyle Engstrom went over. He said he likes your bread, and he can’t tell his wife why he eats it on your bench.”
“Leif. You don’t have to tell me what’s said in there. Marlys told me how that works.”
“It was about your door and your brother. I promised you the hour.” He looked at the bread in his hand. “And I want to. I’ve never wanted to before.”
So he told her all of it, and he did not trim it. He gave her Roy’s words about Nate as near as he could get them, and the gambler with a key, and the shop that paid the club’s bills. He said the part about a president who slept in a bakery, and he did not soften it.
She took that one without flinching. “Well, he’s not wrong about where you sleep.”
“No.”
“What did you say about Nate?”
“That he’s working it off honestly and well. I said I’d tell them first if that changed.”
Her eyes had gone bright. She put her wrist against them for a moment, and he waited.
Then he told her the part she had no way of knowing to ask about. He went back two weeks, to the twenty-fifth of August. Roy had said that Karl, in a bad season, would have kept his eye on the club. Roy had asked whether Leif believed Lusk and the bikes were one problem, or only wanted to.
“I couldn’t answer him,” Leif said. “I sat there in front of eight men with my mouth open. I’d been happy in your kitchen for nine days, and I’d hidden your brother from you that same morning. I didn’t know what I’d believe to keep that couch.”
“And now?”
“Now I believe it. Your tires did that. I’d give a good deal not to have been taught that way.” He turned the last of the braid over. “Tonight he said when it goes bad, it lands on the whole patch. I’ve got no answer to that one either. He may be right. I asked nine men to stand in front of a thing I can’t prove, for a woman I’m in bed with, and five of them said yes. One of those only wants his bike.”
He stopped. He could not remember when he had last said so much at one time. His father had never talked like this to anyone, and neither had Arvid.
Hallie did not tell him it would be all right. He had half expected her to. Making things all right for people was her trade, and she was better at it than anyone he knew.
“I’m not going to say Roy’s wrong,” she said slowly. “I don’t know that he is. If it goes bad, it lands on me first, and then on Nate. After that it’s nine men who ate my pie. I’ve known that since the eleventh of August. I just didn’t know you’d been carrying it at both ends.”
“It’s my chair.”
“I know it is. What do you need from me?”
He thought about it honestly.
“Nothing,” he said. “I needed to say it to somebody who doesn’t vote.”
She leaned into his arm, hard, with her whole shoulder. They sat there until the braid was gone and the step had gone cold under them. He found the stones were still there. But he had set them down between two people, and they weighed about half.
“Five to four,” Hallie said at last. She brushed the crumbs off her apron and stood, and held the door for him. “Then I’d better be worth five.”
“That’s not how it—”
“I know how it works. I’m telling you how I work.” She shot the bolt behind them, and looked up at him with flour on her chin and her mind plainly made up about something. “What time do you shut the bays on a Saturday?”
“Four.”
“Good. I’m coming up there at half past, and I’m going to ask you for something. I want to ask it in your lot.”
***